“The Road Not Taken”
Those words kept echoing in my mind last week as I traveled to Virginia to visit a childhood friend and attend my 45th reunion at the Virginia Military Institute. I had never read Robert Frost’s poem, so I wasn’t channeling him, yet his words perfectly capture the emotions that filled my heart and mind as I revisited a past I had left behind so many years ago.
“Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,And sorry I could not travel bothAnd be one traveler, long I stoodAnd looked down one as far as I couldTo where it bent in the undergrowth;
Then took the other, as just as fair,”
I grew up in a Navy family. From the day I was born in Philadelphia until the day I first walked into the barracks at VMI, my father’s career took us to a new city, a new home, every four years. One of the hardest questions for me to answer is, “Where are you from?”
After graduation, the Marine Corps took me to California and Japan. My civilian career that followed took me back to Virginia for a few years, and then on to Georgia, Ohio, Canada, Oregon, and Colorado.
As I wrote in my last essay, What We Resolve To Be, I lived my life with the unspoken understanding that “What’s behind me is not important.” It was never about consciously choosing to ignore my past, but simply about moving forward.
That’s what left me fighting back tears as I said goodbye to my childhood friend, John, after our stop in Norfolk, before the reunion. It had been thirty years since I’d seen him, and the bond we had shared as teenagers felt just as strong as it once did. There were so many memories. Moments we shared together that forever shaped who I am today.

John taught me to water ski, and then nearly tore my arm off doing it. He and our friend Jerry would drive over to Portsmouth and pick me up from Frederick Military Academy, the boarding school I attended for high school. And John drove me back to Lexington after weekends away from VMI. John was never part of the Corps of Cadets at VMI, but I carried him with me every step of the way.
How could I have never returned to Norfolk in all these years?
And it was the realization that what I'd left behind mattered far more than I'd allowed myself to believe that had me lying awake crying after the first night of our reunion.
Typically, I would chase away strong emotions. It’s what I learned to do as a young boy. It’s what the Rat Line at VMI teaches you. I saw what happens when a Rat at VMI cries in front of an upperclassman. You only need to see that once to know you will NEVER let that happen.
But this time, I did something different. As I lay there, I said to myself, “Just feel what’s there, Chris.”
It’s an incredibly hard thing to do with a strong emotion. I want to solve the problem. Eliminate the discomfort. But to sit and look directly into it without trying to change anything turned out to be incredibly emotional.
Hours passed without any clarity. I thought about the loss of my parents. My brother. The mistakes I have made in my life. I thought about all the good fortune that fills my life these days.

My wife. My daughter. My son. My friends. My health. And I thought about my deteriorating vision and all that it has taught me about myself. And of course, I thought about the bond I had once felt with my Brother Rats at VMI. About how so many of them had stayed connected. Engaged with each other for nearly half a century.
I would love to say that when I woke later that morning, I woke with renewed clarity about my life.
Spoiler alert, I didn’t.
When I first walked into the reunion earlier that day, I had the sense that I was attending someone else’s party, but nothing could have been farther from the truth. The smiles. The hugs. It felt more like five years than 45.
Maybe some of the tears I felt that night were for the time I had lost with a group of men I’d once shared so much with. Or maybe it was the sense that even with all the roads I’d traveled alone, I’d somehow managed to carry them with me over each mile and year.
On Saturday morning, we had a memorial service for the Brother Rats who were no longer with us. With each name that was read, I felt the absence of brothers we’d shared so much with. I felt it most deeply when the name of my roommate, Keith Baron, was called. The world is just a little less bright without him in it, but I know that he, and all our fallen brothers, live on in the memories of those of us who carry them in our hearts.

Now, with a few days’ distance, I think I have a little better sense of the emotions that overwhelmed me that night.
I feel the loss of all the years I missed with my childhood friend, John, in Norfolk, and so many brothers from the VMI Class of 1981. While life took me geographically far from the people who had meant so much to me, I regret not investing more in maintaining those relationships over the years and miles. And I feel blessed that, despite all that time apart, the bonds are still there.
Which brings me back to Frost’s final stanza:
“I shall be telling this with a sighSomewhere ages and ages hence:Two roads diverged in a wood, and I—I took the one less traveled by,And that has made all the difference.”
Frost titled his poem The Road Not Taken, yet he ends by reflecting on the road he did take. I find myself doing much the same. I went back to Virginia thinking about all the years and relationships I'd missed, but I came home with a deeper appreciation for the people and experiences that shaped the person I am today.
I cannot wait for my 50th reunion in five years. And I look forward to staying connected with my dear childhood friend, John, and all the people who have meant so much to me, wherever life’s road has taken us.
In memory of our fallen brothers. Though you no longer walk beside us, each of you helped shape the roads we travel. We would not be the men we are today had our paths never crossed. And we will forever carry you in our hearts with every step.
Ronald M. McCulloch III, October 7, 1979
Robert L. Bobbitt, October 5, 1981
James V. Ovca, March 25, 1987
Alan M. McLachlen, July 31, 1992
Warren S. Williams, October 20, 1994
James P. Irby, August 19, 2001
Gerard A. Mannix, April 20, 2002
Joseph W. McCarthy III, July 23, 2002
Arthur J. Armstead II, February 13, 2004
Michael J. Rattie V, June 23, 2005
William J. McDonald III, January 11, 2006
Robert S. Silverman, June 21, 2008
Scott E. Rittenhouse, September 12, 2012
John W. Judge Jr., January 24, 2013
Robert A. Savage Jr., July 12, 2013
Gordon T. Ivascu, November 20, 2014
Douglas A. Knesal, July 4, 2016
Marcus B. Paine, August 27, 2016
James J. Waller, June 27, 2018
Frank E. Reece, December 6, 2018
James P. Migliarese, December 23, 2018
Charles L. Chipley III, May 23, 2019
Wayne J. Suggs, June 27, 2019
Bruce C. Gottwald Jr., October 20, 2019
Daniel S. Pere, December 19, 2019
John F. Bigger, February 28, 2020
Michael D. Callahan, February 19, 2021
Keith R. Baron, May 29, 2021
William H. Boykin, October 7, 2021
Marc W. Deschambault, November 9, 2022
Douglas W. McCoy, May 29, 2024
Daniel K. Gallagher, August 30, 2024
Steven M. Maurer, February 1, 2025
George A. Gibbs II, September 3, 2025
Edward L. Oast III, December 5, 2025
Gregory D. White, January 30, 2026
Alexandro M. Wright, June 19, 2026




Comments